Young students cheer during an assembly at Bishop O’Connell High School in Arlington, Virginia, Saturday, May 10, 2025. / Credit: EWTN News

CNA Staff, May 17, 2025 / 11:00 am (CNA).

For Catholic students in the United States, the election of Pope Leo XIV as the first American pope on May 8 filled them with excitement and hope.

Or, as one student put it: “Everyone just freaked out.”

Students shared memories of the day with Roselle Reyes, news correspondent for “EWTN News In Depth,” on Friday.

Bahkita Karenge, a Catholic school student in the Diocese of Arlington, Virginia, remembered the excitement of finding out during the school day. Students were “screaming,” “jumping and laughing,” and giving hugs.  

“It was so beautiful because at that moment, it didn’t really matter which sport you played or which friend group you were in or which trend you were following,” Karenge reflected.

“Everyone was just a young Catholic kid, and everyone was excited that we have a new leader.”

Karenge remembered how “everyone joined in” singing the national anthem together after they found out. 

“America represents a lot of different people coming together, so I think [Pope Leo XIV will] really try to make everyone’s voice across the world feel heard, and I think that’s good as a new pope,” Karenge added.

Hopes for ‘revival’ 

Students shared their hopes for what Pope Leo XIV will bring to the world. 

Arlington Catholic student Benjamin Lee observed that Leo is known “from a lot of places around the world” and said he hopes this will “attract” more people to Catholicism. 

The pope grew up in Chicago and spent about a dozen years as a missionary in Peru and has dual citizenship. 

“I hope that more people will become Catholic through that, knowing that he is the first American pope,” Lee said. 

“He’s also Peruvian,” said Catholic student Alison de River. “I’m Peruvian, too, so it makes me really happy.” 

Another student, Andreas Millradt, said he hopes Pope Leo XIV will bring about a “revival.” 

“I hope Pope Leo XIV will bring a new revival to the U.S. to help everyone come to Jesus, learn who he is and what he can do for us,” Millradt said. 

One Catholic school student, Patrick Aogauer, expressed hope that an American pope will show the universality of the Church. 

“I really hope that his new papacy will expand the Catholic Church and show Americans that, yes, it’s universal,” he said. 

‘A frenzy’

Students recounted how special it was to experience such a historical moment with their classmates. 

Millradt remembered that “everyone just freaked out” when they learned the new pope was Cardinal Robert Prevost from the U.S.  

“Everyone went into a frenzy,” Millradt said. “It was incredible.”

“I feel really proud that we have our first American pope, and that it feels like we’re all united,” Millradt continued.

As they were watching the conclave, Millradt said his classmates discussed how they’ve never had an American pope.

“I feel like it was such a blessing being able to see this, such a historical moment and share it with all my schoolmates,” he added. 

Jennifer Meszaros, a local Catholic who attends Our Lady of the Blue Ridge Parish, reflected on how Pope Leo gives young Catholics a deeper connection to the Vatican. 

“I think it brings the Vatican closer to these kids, gives them something tangible, and they can relate to,” Meszaros said. 

“Chicago, they know that,” she continued. “He plays tennis, they play tennis.”

For her part, Meszaros said she hopes the new pope will bring “youth movement back to the Church, which we desperately need for the future of our Church.” 

Bishop Michael Burbidge of Arlington, Virginia, reflected on the “enthusiasm” from young people reacting to the new announcement. 

“There is a real excitement because it represents that the Lord has spoken to us,” Burbidge said. 

He “gave us a new shepherd,” Burbidge continued. “I think young people are responding well to that.”